THE IMPACT: Stimulus bill helped some far more than others

On August 8, 2010, in Impact, by Graydon Gordian

By Graydon Gordian, Kelsey Snell
and Michael Beller
| for McClatchy Newspapers

WASHINGTON — In February 2009, the United States had fallen into what many economists called the deepest economic slowdown since the Great Depression. The housing bubble had burst, unemployment was nearing its highest level in almost three decades and the once-freewheeling banking sector had turned tightfisted.

At the urging of President Barack Obama, Congress passed a $787 billion economic stimulus bill on Feb. 10, 2009, to get federal dollars flowing into the U.S. economy.

Eighteen months later, the administration estimates that about 85 percent of the jobs it expected to create or save in the first two years have indeed been created or saved. The economy is rebounding slowly, and the worst effects of the recession have softened. Unemployment, while still high, is better than it otherwise would have been.

For the most part, mainstream economists such as those at the Congressional Budget Office agree with those conclusions, but an examination by McClatchy and the Medill News Service has found that some parts of the country have benefited far more from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act than others have, that some sectors of the economy are benefiting far more than others are and that it’s difficult to detail exactly where all the money has gone.

Among the findings:

  • The jobless rates in the states had little to do with where major portions of the stimulus package were distributed. Some states with the lowest unemployment rates received some of the highest per-capita spending for stimulus projects. (Graphic: The disconnect between stimulus funds and unemployment by state.)
  • Job creation on the local level has been uneven. By the White House’s numbers, for example, Nebraska created 74 percent of the expected jobs, while North Dakota and Massachusetts created 100 percent.
  • The Obama administration won’t be able to fulfill its vow to track every stimulus dollar. The mechanism that’s used to account for the expenditures is complicated, flawed and at times inaccurate. “I know it’s political rhetoric to say we have to know where every penny is spent,” said Raymond Yee, a lecturer at the University of California Berkeley’s School of Information. “But it’s difficult to even understand where every billion dollars is spent.”
  • Much of the stimulus money has yet to go out the door. As of July, $127 billion in contracts, grants and loans had been awarded, but that’s less than half the $275 billion allocated for those projects.

That’s partly by design and partly because it was difficult to get systems in place to spend money quickly for the array of new programs that the stimulus bill funded.

As it sought to sell the nation on the necessity of a major stimulus package, the White House released 50 information sheets in February 2009 that described how the stimulus would be a boon to every state.

The first selling point in each sheet? Jobs. Whether it was the projected 396,000 jobs created or saved in California or the 8,000 in Vermont, job creation and retention got top billing.

The White House projected creating or saving about 3.5 million jobs in the first two years after the stimulus bill passed. In a July report, the administration estimated that it’s created or saved approximately 3 million of them, about 85 percent of the expected total.
(Using different economic models, the administration calculates the added-jobs tally at either 2.5 million or 3.6 million and averages them out to 3.1 million.)

While they agree that the stimulus package has created jobs, other economists are less optimistic than the White House is. The CBO says the job boost could be as low as 1.4 million or as high as 3.4 million. Three other economic organizations _ all of which the White House cited in its July report _ put the jobs tally at 1.8 million, 2.1 million or 2.2 million.


It’s clear from the McClatchy-Medill analysis of stimulus spending and unemployment, however, that some states have fared much better than others have.

North Dakota has had one of the nation’s lowest unemployment rates for the last year. In June, it hit 3.6 percent. Yet the analysis found that it’s scheduled to receive more stimulus spending, per capita, than is Nevada, where the unemployment rate climbed to 14.2 percent in June.

Part of the disparity is because much of the stimulus spending was doled out based on formulas that were already in place.

Transportation dollars, for example, were distributed to the states based on existing formulas that take into account population, existing roads and other factors. Officials then were directed to consider which parts of their states were “economically distressed,” but that criterion didn’t come into play until after the money had gone to the state capitals.

That means transportation dollars were distributed to states regardless of their economic fortunes. North Dakota and South Dakota, whose unemployment rates are among the lowest in the nation, have more than $250 per capita to spend on recovery act transportation projects. Michigan and Nevada, which have the nation’s highest unemployment rates, will get about $100 per capita for such projects.

Economists who’ve studied the stimulus package say there’s little connection between which states have the worst unemployment and where the stimulus dollars have been spent. Edward Glaeser, a Harvard University economist, wrote in March that, “Stimulus aid was not particularly well matched with need.”

Veronique de Rugy of George Mason University testified before the House of Representatives Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure in March that she and other researchers were unable to find any relationship between unemployment in a given area and the amount of stimulus dollars spent there.

“No matter how we measure unemployment, we find no correlation,” she said.

Though other economists recognize de Rugy’s findings, some disagree with Glaeser and her that funding stimulus programs without regard for local unemployment or economic conditions is a problem.

“If you say, ‘Let’s target states that are doing worse, places that saw the property crash in the worst way,’ ” said Timothy Taylor, the managing editor of the Journal of Economic Perspectives, “is that really the right goal here? This wasn’t just inflicted on them like a lightning bolt. Rewarding failure is never the best plan.”

According to Taylor, the stimulus was intended to be “timely, targeted and temporary,” and state-level funding was meant to prevent state budget shortfalls from contributing to the already slumping economy. Though the system of disbursing money may have been less than ideal, he argues, it was better than creating a complicated distribution system that would have slowed the recovery.

“I think giving (money) to the state governments was probably about as targeted as one could reasonably do,” he said. “It was no more unfair than other possibilities could have been. To have the federal government try to fix things county by county seems insane, especially if you take timely as an important task.”

Administration officials also disagree that targeting communities with high jobless rates would have been a better approach.

“Economic need isn’t bound by county or state lines and, fortunately, neither are the economic benefit of recovery act programs and projects,” said Elizabeth Oxhorn, the recovery act spokeswoman for Vice President Joe Biden. “And when it comes to supporting the hardest-hit among us, assistance like unemployment benefits, tax relief and health care are directly targeted to those who need it most, regardless of where they live.”

“Bottom line: It’s working,” Oxhorn said. “Before the recovery act, our economy was losing an average of 750,000 jobs each month. In the first five months of this year, the economy has created nearly half a million new private-sector jobs.”


Obama also pushed the stimulus bill with a promise that the American people would be able to account for “every penny” that was spent.

A year and a half later, however, and despite spending $18 million to launch an unprecedented system for tracking stimulus bill spending, much of the reported funding information doesn’t match the dollars the federal government says it’s paid.

Although the administration reports how much each government agency has spent, that’s only half the story.

When stimulus dollars are spent, they’re funneled through states, agencies and contractors to the “sub-recipients” that build roads, do research or retrain unemployed workers. After they receive the money, states and recipients are supposed to record how they spend it and report those totals to the federal government.

That’s where things get confusing.

The $280 billion set aside for the states came fast and without clear accounting procedures. Moreover, the federal government didn’t include any money for states to hire the people necessary to track the deluge of money.

“I joke that the (stimulus) money came in the nick of time and the worst time,” said Kinney Poynter, the executive director of the National Association of State Auditors, Comptrollers and Treasurers. “Many states were already short staffed. And really there were no policies and procedures that happened this quick and of this magnitude before.”

States had seven months from the day the stimulus bill was signed to the first time they were expected to report on how they’d spent the money. Small state-level staffs were flooded with new terminology, coding numbers, data keys and reporting websites. Many were confused.

The McClatchy-Medill review of state audits found that money sometimes went to poorly organized programs; other times, reporting demands conflicted with other federal guidelines.

Ultimately, beyond the costs of transparency mandates in time and money, states and contractors were confused and oversight was scattered, according to the state audits.

One agency that generated concern among auditors was the Department of Education, which so far has paid out more than $50 billion in stimulus money.

According to Charles Willson of the Government Accountability Office, it was difficult to account for education spending even before the stimulus. Giving educators more money didn’t improve accounting; it just meant there was more to account for.

“Maybe no one knows where this money has gone,” said Yee, the University of California Berkeley lecturer. “Whenever you have thousands of people fill out a form to submit to the government, it’s going to be messy, but there is no clear accounting here. The stimulus wasn’t meant to be a national jigsaw puzzle.”

Barry Bosworth of The Brookings Institution, a center-left Washington policy-research organization, pointed to another problem with the stimulus program: the lagging speed of spending. The stimulus “was originally meant to stop the collapse,” Bosworth said. “The problem with it: It was too slow.”

With the national unemployment rate still well above 9 percent, many Americans are wondering whether the stimulus measure has been a success.

In a February Pew Research Center poll, 49 percent of Americans said they disapproved of the stimulus plan, an increase from June 2009, when 39 percent disapproved. A June 2010 poll that involved the same organization found that 60 percent of respondents said the stimulus hadn’t helped the nation’s job situation.

Mainstream economists, however, say the measure generally has been successful.

John Schmitt of the Center for Economic and Policy Research said that America would have been worse off without the stimulus package; he estimates that unemployment could have been as high as 13 percent.

“The economics of it is not controversial,” Schmitt said. “It has been masked by politics.”

Added Diane Lim Rogers, the chief economist at the Concord Coalition, a nonprofit budget watchdog group: “In terms of boosting the level of economic activity beyond what would’ve occurred with the stimulus, I’m sure it worked,” she said. “The question of how great a piece of legislation it is, you have to be more measured in that response. Did it work enough to justify its cost?”

McClatchy’s Chris Adams and Northwestern University Medill School of Journalism’s Alice Truong, Lauren Drell, Mari Fagel, Jessica Binsch, Eleanor Goldberg and Christina Lee contributed to this article; the students graduated in June.

More from McClatchy


168 Responses to “THE IMPACT: Stimulus bill helped some far more than others”

  1. Hi buddy, your blog’s model is simple and clean and i like it. Your blog content are superb. Please preserve them coming. Greets!!!

  2. Thanks for your very informative post, I have bookmarked your site, thanks much!

  3. tv brackets – My wife and i both enjoyed your informative post. gracias.

  4. good post, added you to my RSS reader.

  5. Kari Burrus says:

    nice! i can tell this was important! good job!

  6. good post, added you to my RSS reader.

  7. I had a dream to start my own firm, nevertheless I did not have got enough amount of money to do it. Thank God my fellow proposed to utilize the credit loans. Therefore I took the credit loan and made real my desire.

  8. guess what? I like what you wrote, added you to my FeeBurner.

  9. So how many occasions have I read a post and figured what a waste of my own spare time that ended up being. Certainly certainly not this particular occasion .

  10. Just wanted to comment and say that I really like your blog layout and the way you write too. It’s very refreshing to see a blogger like you.. keep it up

  11. Just like someone else announced what a wonderful blog this is. Generally I dont make an effort with a remark still for your effort you ought to get one. Very well done

  12. zamHikferzy Watch Live NFL Football Abokfobeur IrvinViverezze VernonRaczegar zhereciamemmozz

  13. the put up photographs arent repowering to do

  14. nice! i can tell this was important! good job!

  15. good post, added you to my RSS reader. Hope it works with my FeedBurner

  16. There are some interesting points in time in this clause but I don’t know if I see all of them centre to eye . There is some validness but I will hold opinion until I look into it further. Good article , thanks and we want more! Added to FeedBurner also.

  17. You are not the common blog author, man. You certainly have something important to add to the web. Such a outstanding blog. I will return for more.

  18. Good for you, master writer. You are one of a kind.

  19. Gilda Rentz says:

    I then go back to a that formulates an education for a.

  20. That Coalition economics policy in full; “We’re filthy rich, so sod the rest of you!”

  21. puan says:

    Hi; Great informations for me. Your post has valuable infos. I wish to has good posts like yours in my blog. How do you find these posts?

  22. That’s actually an amazing.

  23. I certainly have my share of.

  24. Hello; Excellent post for me. Your post has valuable infos. I wish to has good posts like yours in my website. How do you write these posts?

  25. OK, my pal announced, Sometimes you get the bar and sometimes the bar gets you.

  26. DU Refi Plus says:

    What a great blog, thank you for letting me comment on it.

  27. Eight in ten advisors said they deal with the concept that more significant than ever.

  28. oyun oyna says:

    Hello; Excellent post for me. Your post has good quality. I want to has good posts like yours in my website. How do you make these posts?

  29. This was a practical choice.

  30. e okul says:

    Hi; Great post for me. Your post has valuable infos. I wish to has valuable posts like yours in my blog. How do you find these posts?

  31. There’s a first time for this.

  32. Hi; Great post for me. Your post has valuable infos. I want to has valuable posts like yours in my blog. How do you write these posts?

  33. oyunlar1 says:

    Let all 3 ride together – Hilary would be an improvement!

  34. porno says:

    Thanks very good \o/

  35. Maybe you have known of any website that is just like this Drivers Education Essay,English Composition Writing on Drivers Education,Example Drivers Education Essays? Sincerely… By the way, I am Olivia Aw and I am a teacher of foreign students living in Quebec.

  36. düzce haber says:

    Thanks very good \o/

  37. Perhaps I may be having a wrong-headed pertaining to it.

  38. Would it be alright to syndicate your feed?

  39. You just want to sit down and do this.

  40. escort bayan says:

    Thanks very good \o/

  41. mirc sohbet says:

    Thanks very good \o/

  42. Great article, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing a little research on this. And he in fact purchased me breakfast because I discovered it for him. :).. So let me reword that: Thanks for the treat! But yeah Thnkx for taking the time to talk about this, I feel strongly about it and enjoy learning more on this topic. If possible, as you become expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more details? It is very helpful for me. Big thumb up for this blog post!

  43. oyunlar says:

    Thanks very good \o/

  44. hileler says:

    Thanks very good \o/

  45. Keep working ,great job!

  46. gyms says:

    Super-Duper site! I am loving it!! Will come back again – taking you feeds also, Thanks.

  47. Prnhub says:

    Thanks very good \o/

  48. Exactly laqr,I think I’m smarter than Obama too. and to prove it, I’ll put my college GPA and transcripts up against his any day.

  49. What a great blog, thank you for letting me comment on it.

  50. Hey, thanks for the blog.Really thank you! Keep writing.

  51. It should be crystal clear to you that these are the typical thoughts in regard to.

  52. Say, you got a nice blog article.Really thank you! Want more.

  53. A big thank you for your article.

  54. diziler says:

    great thanks man…

  55. müzik indir says:

    great thanks man…

  56. Jared Leto says:

    Great website, I found it really useful, hope you keep posting new material.

  57. IGXE says:

    Great website, I found it really useful, hope you keep posting new material.

  58. SEO Packages says:

    Great website, I found it really useful, hope you keep posting new material.

  59. Loved the website, amazing info I’ll bookmark it

  60. izle says:

    great thanks man…

  61. Noma Hyland says:

    But, whatever gives you a thrill.

  62. program says:

    thanks great =)

  63. Kivine says:

    Hi there, I found your blog via Google while searching for first aid for a heart attack and your post looks very interesting for me.

  64. Doing that is on the cutting edge.

  65. beslenme says:

    great thanks man…

  66. chat says:

    video izlemenin keyfi ile çıkar.

  67. video izlemenin keyfi ile çıkar.

  68. This is a method for beginning with this.

  69. Thank you so much for posting this article. It’s really helped me a lot. You’re a great writer.

  70. In this installment, I shall to provide you with an example of what I’m talking about with reference to.

  71. excelent web good info congrats. To get the best ganar dinero en internet advice click on the link

  72. It is phenomenal how infantile people must avoid a clear cut concern like this.

  73. excelent web good info congrats. To get the best casino games advice click on the link

  74. porno says:

    good thanks \o/

  75. I have accomplished this with.

  76. Sagteware says:

    [url=]educational applications[/url] rfgdfgh ytyt trtrsrt ghgh [url=]sound drivers[/url] [url=]internet calling[/url] thd hjytgh ryted dfg [url=]converter software[/url] fthgt trygh y yurt [url=]voice dictating[/url] rytrt6yu tr dknj ljf ouye njfjlk [url=]security threat software[/url] rfg riojkl slkj nhju oji iol [url=]background software[/url] rgsdergrg trsf gfh ghdfsht thtrsdgthth tyhhhtrh [url=]network managing application[/url] sthheeiuhjnfkdv iunjjk oij oiajvj mkl [url=]itunes software[/url] fbvfsd trht tghhsdf [url=]internet surfing software[/url] sfdhg thsdfgg sdgtr [url=]web browsers[/url] strhf frsrg trht sdgtrtr tstsfhhtu [url=]programming developer[/url] ru ghsdtst trghgth thtr werrg [url=]family software[/url]gwegr trhhdrs tthyj utrj [url=]computer game software[/url] ytjuytj jytj [url=]email[/url] ytjye eytj jtj uy kykjk kyu [url=]update drivers[/url] r7yu yudf ytj ytrt6 tyj [url=]desktop widgets[/url]ytjt6uydhj ytjuyr dyj djyj yj [url=]home designing software[/url]j dyjud yjdyj [url=]computer systems[/url] ydj ikl jbdddn dfgdtr tdt gtrsdr [url=]book keeping software[/url]

  77. They should change Earth Day to Carbon Emissions Day to celebrate all the Global Warming spazzes flying around in their private jets.

  78. Excellent post. Very informative. Thanks for writing this.

  79. Zune and iPod: Most people compare the Zune to the Touch, but after seeing how slim and surprisingly small and light it is, I consider it to be a rather unique hybrid that combines qualities of both the Touch and the Nano. It’s very colorful and lovely OLED screen is slightly smaller than the touch screen, but the player itself feels quite a bit smaller and lighter. It weighs about 2/3 as much, and is noticeably smaller in width and height, while being just a hair thicker.

  80. gmina says:

    Pretty right article. I just came across your web site and loved to express that I have really enjoyed reading your opinions. AnyhowI’ll be coming back and I hope you post again soon.

  81. Amazing article. Very helpful. Thank you for sharing.

  82. I arrived here seeing as this blog had been tweeted by a gentleman I had been following and am happy I made it here.

  83. Cody says:

    Bellasera Resort – Naples Hotel
    221 9th Street South, Naples, FL 34102

  84. Heya! Wonderful piece of writing! I am a daily visitor (very much like addict :P) of this website but I had a difficulty. I am only not necessarily absolutely certain if it is the right web site to ask, but you’ve got no spam comments. I recieve comments similar to DPTcmMwatch movies onlinezlWeRBf every single day. Are able to you help me? With thanks.

  85. online izle says:

    good (article|information) thanks

  86. Shayne Pede says:

    When you are getting your personal ipad period, perhaps you should also possess your personal apple ipad Situation and apple ipad Add-ons to higher protect the actual apple ipad. When you arrived at the website, the first you should know is you can buy the highest quality and many costly ipad situation, additionally your preferred apple ipad cases as well as ipad add-ons. There are 100s kinds of ipad situation

  87. I just couldnt leave your website before singing you that we really enjoyed the helpful info you supply to your visitors… Will be back soon to check up on other posts

  88. I’d like to begin my personal blog one day. This was a really nice weblog that you produced here. Keep up the good work.

  89. Evelina Mee says:

    Outstanding article and genuinely helps with understanding the article much better.

  90. milliyetci says:

    Thanks for post \o/

  91. Dylan Dumler says:

    is one element that still remains constant in a changing world and has been a labor of love.

  92. wow, awesome post.Thanks Again. Really Great.

  93. Barrett Mire says:

    Thank you for this wonderful post. Have been bored in operate all working day till I stumbled across this put up, actually obtained me considering about some stuff

  94. I had issues with your website on my browser and had to refresh the page a couple of times…

  95. sikiş izle says:

    good (article|information) thanks

  96. Man, really want to know how can you be that smart, lol…great read, thanks.

  97. zwrot podatku z holandia, praca na terenie holandii, zwrot podatku holandia, odzyskaj zwrot podatku

  98. oto kiralama says:

    great thanks

  99. oyun indir says:

    great thanks

  100. Amazing site, loved it

  101. I understand this really is really boring and you’re simply missing to the next remark, however I simply wished to throw a large thanks – a person solved some things personally!

  102. Hi, Well this was definitely something new, I really liked it as I am new to this

  103. porno says:

    thanks for post

  104. Would you mind if I reference a few sentences from your post? I’m researching for project for highschool. Thanks!

  105. Worry is spiritual short sight. Its cure is intelligent faith.

  106. dizi izle says:

    Evet dizilerde hep daha mükemmel hayatlar izleniyor ve insanlar kendi hayatlarındaki eksiklerin farkına varıp,

  107. Hey, I searched for this blog upon Bing and just wished to state just excellent study. I would need to trust it, thanks again!

  108. Hi there could I use some of the material from this blog if I provide a link back to your site?

  109. interesting post, keep it up

  110. Like someone else said what a great blog this is. Typically I dont make an effort with a comment then again for your effort and hard work you ought to get one. Very well done

  111. great thanks

  112. Program says:

    good information

  113. Poker zasady says:

    Worry is spiritual short sight. Its cure is intelligent faith. : )

  114. Perfect piece we have to spread the word about this web site.You need to have additional attention .

  115. Yo! Stunning content! I am just a regular website visitor (somewhat more like addict :P) on your website however I had a problem. I’m just never totally sure whether its the right place to question, but there are no spam comments. I recieve comments for example lPzDdfwatch movies onlinetUteYof daily. Are able to you help me? I am grateful.

  116. Jack says:

    To start earning money with your blog, initially use Google Adsense but gradually as your traffic increases, keep adding more and more money making programs to your site.

  117. emo nick says:

    thanks, great article

  118. escort bayan says:

    good, great article

  119. TLD says:

    ziaWeczab Domain Name Bennezzzinbak czewarzohn ochuaPavic ayemarb

  120. Taekwondo says:

    Greetings its me one more time basically , thought I would pop back and look at in which way the conversation was in fact really going.

  121. Kardashian says:

    Hi. Very interesting site. I found it on Yahoo. I will definately recommend it to my friends. Please keep up the great work.

  122. Dbol says:

    Glad i recently uncovered this website, Another good site is Dbol will make sure to book mark it so i can stop by frequently.

  123. Hey, i’ve been reading this web site for a while and have a question, maybe you can help… it’s how do i add your feed to my rss reader as i want to follow you. Cheers.

  124. Brilliant blog and definitely aids with learning the article much better.

  125. nice short article. you are really a outstanding blogger. i benefit from your articles a whole lot. thank you.

  126. Hi, wanted to show my thanks a lot for your quality blog post. its incredible refreshing to see a quality blog lately.

  127. Sam Jones says:

    Very good blog, lots of valuable details.

  128. Great job. Good article I must say.